This shows that his story couldn’t be true because the location described and the actual location didn’t match up. In addition to these aspects, all of the recorded locations of the calls did not ping on towers where Jay described they were. This time proves that Adnan couldn’t have done the murder. So, the overall time was possibly plausible, but it was hard to believe.
#Serial podcast worksheets episode 5 full
It took her 22:02 to get the full reenactment of Jay’s timeline of events completed. It took Sarah (the narrator of Serial) 12 minutes to get to Best Buy from the school. Also, the reenactment of the timeline that Jay offered to the police did not match Jay’s story. No picture or blueprint of the building contains any evidence of the phone booth. For example, the phone booth that Jay described Adnan using after committing the murder is not on any building or phone record. The events that Jay described did not match the timeline or the location of the pings from the phone calls. Chris Kane: After listening to Episode 5 of Serial, I theorize that Jay manipulated Adnan and the police into believing that Adnan actually did commit the murder.While the results were hard to follow, the inconsistencies of Jay’s supposed “true” telling of what happened to Hae Min Lee lead me to theorize that Jay is either responsible for her murder or knows something that hasn’t yet been discovered. Madeline: In this episode, Sarah experiments with the cell phone records matching the timeline provided by the prosecution, Adnan, and Jay.
However, Jay's timing is off and doesn't match up with the times on the phone log. Which looks bad for Adnan because even he admits that he was with his phone at that time. All locations that are supported by the cell towers. After that Jay tells the police that they ditched Hae's body in Leakin Park, her car at Edmondson Avenue, and got rid of the evidence at Westview Mall. The call matches the cell tower, call log, Jay's story, Adnan's story, and Cathy's story. Until around 6:30, that puts Adnan and Jay together because of a call (the one where the police asked Adnan if he's seen Hae) that was made on Adnan's phone near Jay's anonymous friend's, who's named Cathy, apartment. In a six hour time frame, the towers, the calls, and Jay's story aren't matching up. The cell expert and prosecutor went around testing the 12 important sites according to Jay's story and only bring up four sites in court because it didn't support their case. Sarah discusses how it's been proven that phone records prove where someone wasn't rather where someone was. He claims he picked up Adnan at 6 but a call was made to one of Adnan's friends, Krista, around 5:30 and the call is near the place where Hae's car was ditched. There's another problem with Jay's story. The track coach also doesn't remember Adnan being late, but he's not 100% sure. At 6 PM, Jay picks up Adnan again and makes a note that he said goodbye to Will, his track friend that was never questioned by the police. The call isn't made near the school though like Jay says.
Jay also talks of a call Adnan got in a foreign language while he about to drive off Adnan at practice, a regular thing for them. Also, later in court, Jay never mentions this trip to the park, another inconsistency. However, going there makes it impossible of Adnan to be on time to make it to track practice, at 4, his alibi. According to Jay, they stayed for twenty to thirty minutes and Adnan told Jay how he killed Hae. Sarah and Dana continue on to Patapsco State Park, next on the timeline, where Adnan and Jay smoke. Other calls made later also don't match the locations that Jay told the police. Also, Jay says the call was made at a golf course but a cell tower pings the location west of the Best Buy where Hae was supposed killed. However, Adnan claims that he wasn't with Jay at the time, he was at school. Another call is made to a girl Adnan flirted with, Nisha, and is important to the story because it's the only call during this time to someone Adnan actually knows but apparently, Jay also talked to her. Adnan and Jay apparently drove together to buy weed and someone made a call to Jenn, one of Jay's friends.
Sarah and Dana continue to follow the timeline, continuing on after Hae's murder. The State also presents Adnan's phone records, how it justifies the story based on where cell towers pinged the location of the calls.
0 kommentar(er)
